Lunar Threads

my favorites in order

episode V empire strikes back- i love the battle on hoth
episode III revenge of the sith
episode I phantom menace
episodeIV a new hope
episode VI return of the jedi
episode II attack of the clones

Here's my order:

Episode V
Episode VI
Episode III
Episode IV
Episode I
Episode II

i wonder if episode II will get any votes

I never liked Episode II all that much, and I heard that a lot of people didn't, so I wonder how many people would.

I agree with you on that. Besides, I just didn't like the plot of Episode II all that much.

Agree with you on that, too.

I can't place them in a precise order, but this is where they'd tend to fall.

Episode V
Episode IV
Episode III
Episode VI
Episode I
Episode II

The thing is, I don't even think that Episode II is a horrible movie or anything. It's just not truly great for me.

As for Empire Strikes Back, I love the Millennium Falcon. ^^

cool episode V still kickin butt

Return of the Jedi, hands down. Most lightsaber action around when I grew up. And the battle in space was just spectacular for me. I like episodes 1-3, but somethings between the old ones and the new ones just doesn't work out.

I.E. In one of the old episodes, Obi-won mentioned that Yoda trained him, where as in the movies it was Qui-gon.

So yeah, I caught little things like that.

Yoda still trained him. Just because QuiGon was his mentor doesn't mean he didn't learn from Yoda as well.

Empire Strikes Back, it has Luke before he is a full fledged Jedi and also has the incredible fight on Hoth, one of my favorite movie scenes of all time.

my favorite is the revenge of the sith

III
I
VI
V
IV
II

I loved Revenge of The Sith. And I too, am not saying that Clone Wars sucks. I loved the Geonosis battle. That was the best of them all. But that's the only reason why I ever watch it. And Revenge of The Sith picked up all the pieces of the puzzle. Why did Darth Vader become Darth Vader? How did Padame die? Etc. It's all there. It was one of the few prologues I actually liked. And, it kinda minorly freaked me out when Vader killed the kids. I knew they wanted to show that he was now evil, but that was a bit over-kill. Just talking the way he did would have been enough. But nooooooooo. He had to slaughter the innocent. Oh well. Not all great movies are perfect.

V all the way. IV is a close second though. VI could have been almost on par with them, but Ewoks defeating the Imperial army was just stupid.

I, II, and III just didn't have the magic. Horrible dialogue and Razzie caliber acting may have had something to do with it...

Heres mine:
III
IV
I
V
VI
II

I really liked III.

Heres mine:
3
6
5
4
2
1

3 hade the best fleet battles

I still don't get why III is getting such high numbers, above even the originals. ...must be some generational thing. KF

I liked III, but it just can't be anywhere as good as the originals. Besides... it took two awful movies to set it up. It was good, but not good enough to watch two bad movies before it.

Edit: Syntax and semantics. I need to proofread these better.

I can't believe Empire Strike's back has such good numbers. I mean, as far as I am concerned it ranks lower than the new movies, which of course rank lower than the originals.

The best part of the new movies is the light saber fights. Yeah, now THAT'S how its done!

phyco126 wrote:I can't believe Empire Strike's back has such good numbers. I mean, as far as I am concerned it ranks lower than the new movies, which of course rank lower than the originals.

Really? Even worse than Phantom Menace? Really? You must really like pod races, annoying kids, and two-dimensional villains (okay... that one's a given for pretty much all of us since we are on an RPG forum) .